The twenty-first century has brought major changes to the workplace with advancements in technology, remote work, workforce diversity, and a growing focus on employee well-being. All the staples of a high-trust workplace.
It would be hard to argue that the workplace has not become a more welcoming and enjoyable place than it was even 25 years ago. No longer can employers view their employees simply as a means for production because employees have fought for more rights as workers and know their value.
While many of these advances are society-driven and a result of a more progressive mindset on labor relations in general, there is still a mistrust in HR and leadership. This perception of HR and leadership is detrimental to building a high-trust workplace.
It’s no secret that HR works closely with the leadership of their organization up to the CEO. HR must mitigate risk where possible and provide guidance to leadership. Unfortunately, though, this relationship between HR and leadership is common knowledge and can create the perception that HR will always advocate for the company over the employee. Employees may view HR as a safe space only to feel as though they were treated as a liability rather than a human being with a grievance. There is a lack of confidence that HR will represent them without bias.
- According to a survey conducted by Secure Data Recovery, over a third of employees do not trust HR and 43% don’t feel comfortable sharing concerns with HR.
- ARRIS Composites found that 34% of employees surveyed would not approach HR because of a lack of trust.
Ouch. That’s rough. Many reports suggest trust in HR has seen minimal increases following the COVID-19 pandemic, however, there is work to do to repair the relationship between HR and the workforce.
Understanding why this perception exists is the first step toward changing it. For the full picture on what drives it, read What Everyone Gets Wrong About HR (And Why It Is Costing Them).
The perception of HR could simply be a symptom of their own views on corporations, or it could be from a bad personal experience (as if the TikTok videos and Facebook posts weren’t enough!). Either way, it is possible to shift these perceptions and build trust with your employees.
That trust starts with knowing their information and concerns will be confidential. HR must uphold their end of the bargain when an employee brings concerns forward and use best practices when handling sensitive information. So, what does that look like as an HR professional?
Be Transparent
Honesty at the surface seems so simple but once you begin peeling back the layers it can become incredibly complex. We begin to ask ourselves if being honest will do things like negatively impact the relationship, create more problems than it solves, or hurt our credibility. These thoughts are not mutually exclusive to the workplace, we have these same dilemmas in our personal lives, and we often have the best intentions but only make things worse when we aren’t transparent.
Of course, there may be times when transparency is not possible, where there needs to be an intentional approach to messaging. By sharing what can be shared and providing updates along the way you reduce the risk of appearing untrustworthy.
Timing is Everything
An employee comes to you sharing personal information like a medical condition that requires accommodations or a coworker harassing them – now place yourself in their shoes and think about how you would want to be treated in one of these situations.
We won’t try reading your mind, but we think being treated fairly, with respect and dignity, and trusting that the person you are confiding in isn’t going to go and tell everyone would be some of the common themes. What else? We all want to know that our concerns are being taken seriously and addressed appropriately. When people are stressed or anxious, they want relief fast from the stimulus creating these feelings and many times when an employee comes to HR these are the exact emotions they are experiencing.
These are all reasons why responding quickly and communicating throughout the process with the employee is important to maintaining positive relations.
Provide Closure
Have you ever provided a seemingly simple solution for an employee and received a heartfelt thank you? It’s one of the most rewarding parts of being in HR but it speaks to something very fundamental about the relationship between HR and employees. Usually, if an employee reaches out to HR, they are dealing with something that, at least in their mind, is urgent and perhaps causing anxiety.
So, providing a timely response is important even if that response is simply that their concern was received and setting expectations around follow-up. Sometimes they may expect instant agreement or turnaround but just level-setting with them can go a long way toward building trust.
Where possible though, HR should provide a timeline for looking into their concern and an anticipated follow-up. Unfortunately, HR doesn’t always provide a solution that makes everyone happy, but we still need to close the loop.
For example, Amy Mosher, an HR supervisor on the team responsible for HR investigations at a Fortune 500 company, explains that she advises her team to follow up frequently with the claimant throughout the investigation process and to provide closure to all parties afterwards.
Amy has seen the impact it can have on employees when they feel like HR is taking their concerns seriously by listening and by taking action even when the specific actions taken are not shared. She says there are many times when a complaint is inconclusive or not substantiated and while this can be a frustration for the employee who filed a formal complaint her team always shares their findings – the gratitude expressed is one of Amy’s favorite parts about being in HR and why she loves being in a profession that plays a part in building a high-trust workplace.
“Going through that process with an employee creates a bond. Whether they like it or not”, says Amy as she laughs. “You see each other in the cafeteria or walking out to your car after work and there is an actual conversation versus an obligatory head nod. It’s a feeling that’s palpable”, she says with a smile.
Organizations often fall into the trap of categorizing initiatives as employee engagement and building their strategies around it. The problem with this approach is that when they don’t see turnover decrease or engagement scores increase they are at a loss. This is likely because there isn’t a focus on how employees are supported and advocated for.
Don’t get us wrong. We love a good company picnic as much as anyone (we all know HR knows how to plan a party), but HR’s impact is in the daily interactions with employees. HR initiatives without the appropriate people support could have the opposite effect of what was intended by hurting trust.
With so many factors influencing employees’ perceptions of HR and their organizations, it can feel like we’re always behind and unable to move the needle. Often, we get so caught up in building better systems and processes that we forget to focus on the foundation of the human-to-human connection.
High-trust workplaces operate with a baseline of providing transparency, following up, and seeing things through to the finish.
Check out more articles on a high-trust workplace!
- Culture Creep: The Consequence of Not Listening to Employees
- Why the Partnership Between HR and Leadership is Essential to a High-Trust Workplace
- Workplace Illusions: Why the Optics Matter
- How HR Can Protect Employee Privacy and Change Perception in the Workplace
- The Curse of Confidentiality in the Workplace: Why Withholding Information Does More Harm Than Good
